• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Matthew Ward Writes

Short story author, Novelist in the making & Grammar enthusiast

  • About me
  • Grammar Blogs
  • Lessons from Reading
  • Short Stories
  • Show Search
Hide Search

‘However’ and commas

Matthew Ward · 16/10/2020 · 1 Comment

Here’s a simple grammar principle that’s well worth remembering:

Where there is ‘however’, there should always be a comma nearby.

That comma can come in one of two places, and over the next few minutes, I’ll help you make that choice of locations as simple as possible. 

Location 1: When ‘however’ means ‘but’

Take a look at these examples:

We climbed all day yesterday. However, we only ascended a few feet.

I heard you enjoy fishing. I’m not so keen on it, however.

This has been a wonderful day. I am, however, beginning to feel tired.

In the first example, ‘however’ can be directly swapped for ‘but’, and the meaning of the sentence will stay the same:

We climbed all day yesterday, but we only ascended a few feet.

In the other sentences, if we move ‘however’ to the start of the sentence, we can do the same thing. Yet again, the meaning of each sentence would stay the same:

I heard you enjoy fishing, but I’m not so keen on it.

This has been a wonderful day, but I am beginning to feel tired.

In all these examples where ‘however’ can be swapped for ‘but’, we can now notice the location of the commas. They separate ‘however’ from the rest of the sentence so that ‘however’ sits alone. This means that the commas can come before, after, or on either side of ‘however’ depending on whether ‘however’ comes at the end, the beginning, or in the midst of the sentence, respectively.

Wherever ‘however’ is placed, this is the vital point to remember: If ‘however’ can be swapped for ‘but’, a comma separates ‘however’ from the rest of the sentence so that ‘however’ sits alone.

This is our first comma location.

Location 2: When ‘however’ means ‘no matter how’

Take a look at these examples:

However long it takes, get the job done.

I’d like you to finish everything, however hard that turns out to be.

I’ll bring it all, however much we need, to the gathering tomorrow.

In each of these examples, ‘however’ can be swapped for ‘no matter how’, and the meaning of the sentence will stay the same:

No matter how long it takes, get the job done.

I’d like you to finish everything, no matter how hard that turns out to be.

I’ll bring it all, no matter how much we need, to the gathering tomorrow.

Notice the commas. Unlike the previous location, where the commas only separated ‘however’ from the rest of the sentence, in this situation, ‘however’ introduces a phrase, and that entire phrase is separated from the rest of the sentence. Yet again, commas will come before, after, or on either side of the phrase depending on its location in the sentence.

But wherever the phrase is placed, this is the vital point to remember: If ‘however’ can be swapped for ‘no matter how’, a comma separates the entire phrase that ‘however’ introduces, so that the phrase sits apart from the rest of the sentence.

This is our second comma location.

And, guess what, there’s no room for confusion.

Notice that the examples of the first location would make no sense if ‘however’ were swapped for ‘no matter how’ instead of ‘but’:

We climbed all day yesterday. No matter how we only ascended a few feet.

The inverse is true of any example from the second location:

But long it takes, get the job done.

This fact makes me feel particularly confident about my choice of comma location. 

In summary

This is the first thing to remember:

Where there is ‘however’, there should always be a comma nearby.

Then remember that there are two possible places for that comma to go.

If ‘however’ can be swapped for ‘but’, a comma separates ‘however’ from the rest of the sentence so that ‘however’ sits alone.

If ‘however’ can be swapped for ‘no matter how’, a comma separates the entire phrase that ‘however’ introduces, so that the phrase sits apart from the rest of the sentence.

It’s as simple as that. I hope this solves one more comma-placement conundrum and makes your writing process a little easier.

Happy writing!

And for lots more punctuation pointers, check out My Big Blog Directory.

But if you’d like some entertainment instead, take a look at Glimpses—my free book of short stories.

Filed Under: Grammar Blogs Tagged With: comma, commas, English grammar, English punctuation, grammar, punctuation

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. Could I help you write? My Big Blog Directory - Matthew Ward Writes says:
    06/03/2021 at 11:57

    […] the meaning of a whole sentence? A simple guide to placing commas before ‘which’ and ‘that’ ‘However’ and commas MicroBlog 1: Commas, Names, and not eating […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

About Me

I’m a nineteen-year-old budding writer with a passion for grammar, short stories, and novels.

More About Me

Search posts

Follow Me

  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Find the post for you

  • About me
  • Grammar Blogs
  • Lessons from Reading
  • Short Stories

Copyright © 2022

Privacy Policy

“What about milk?” Debbie asked. Mark reached for the milk. “Let me see.” He shook the carton. “There’s only a drop left.” “I’ll add it to the list.”

This paragraph includes several mistakes.

The paragraph starts with Debbie’s dialogue. Then, it moves to Mark’s. Then, it returns to Debbie’s. We need to start new paragraphs with each new speaker.

And we need to make sure that information about Debbie is alongside her dialogue, and information about Mark is placed alongside his dialogue.

When we put this into action we get this:

“What about milk?” Debbie asked.

Mark reached for the milk. “Let me see.” He shook the carton. “There’s only a drop left.”

“I’ll add it to the list.”

Now that’s perfect.

Mark, standing in the kitchen and hearing her call, opened the fridge. “I think,” Debbie continued, “we might be low on cheese.”

This paragraph includes a mistake. The dialogue in the paragraph is Debbie’s. Therefore, information that is primarily about Mark shouldn’t be in the same paragraph.

This is how it should be written:

Mark, standing in the kitchen and hearing her call, opened the fridge.

“I think,” Debbie continued, “we might be low on cheese.”

Mark moved one block of cheddar and checked behind it. “No, we’ve got two blocks.”

This paragraph is perfect. It involves Mark’s dialogue and information about Mark.

“Have we got enough groceries to last the week?” Debbie shouted from the living room.

This paragraph is perfect. It involves Debbie’s dialogue and information about Debbie.


There’s no need to wait for my next post because I’ve got an offer for you.
I’ll edit the punctuation and grammar in any two paragraphs of your writing for free.
You could choose the most awkward ones if you like!
(I’d probably do that if I were you.)
Then, when I return your paragraphs, I’ll include full explanations of every edit so that you can apply them to the rest of your writing. I’d love to help.
For more information and to take up my offer, click here.